Tesla may have gained fame as a pioneer in electric vehicles, but its reputation for reliability is questionable. Despite high customer satisfaction ratings, Tesla consistently ranks poorly in reliability tests conducted by top industry authorities such as J.D. Power and Consumer Reports.

According to reports, Tesla vehicles have an average of 171 mechanical issues per 100 vehicles. Compared to the industry average of around 120 problems per 100 vehicles, this raises concerns about the reliability of Tesla cars. If you are considering buying a Tesla, it is essential to dig deeper into the actual cost of ownership before making a decision.

Using the latest data from the carmaker’s websites, media press releases, and interviews by reputable sources, we have compiled the most recent information available.

Updated on September 12, 2023: In light of Tesla’s presence in the market for several years, we have decided to refresh and update this list to provide you with the latest information. Stay tuned for more updates and fresh insights.

Related: Most Common Problems With New Tesla EVs

Tesla Reliability Trends Explored

Tesla currently offers four models: the Model S, Model 3, Model X, and the Model Y. These models have an EPA-estimated range of over 300 miles, advanced features, and a comfortable ride. However, it is crucial to understand the level of dependability when considering a Tesla purchase. Consumer Reports ranked Tesla 27th out of 28 automakers in terms of dependability.

Tesla Predicted Reliability Ratings By Consumer Reports

Tesla’s low reliability rating is partly due to frequent fires reported in the past. The company has issued several recalls to address these serious issues. However, it’s important to note that battery fires are not uncommon in the EV market due to the heat generated by EV batteries. Until the industry finds a solution to this problem, it’s something to keep an eye on.

While it’s useful to know a manufacturer’s overall reliability, understanding specific models is even more important. By researching the reliability of each Tesla model, you can make an informed decision about which one best suits your needs. Additionally, it’s crucial to investigate the specific problems that have affected reliability ratings, as not all issues may be relevant to your situation.

Related: 10 Ways Tesla Has Reshaped The Automotive Industry

Commonly Reported Issues With Tesla Cars

Tesla’s poor reliability reputation is mainly due to issues with the Model S, X, and Y produced between 2019 and 2021. The reliability of the Model 3, which Consumer Reports still recommends, is average. Common complaints from Model Y owners include faulty sensors, heat pump problems, air conditioning issues, misaligned body panels, water leaks in the trunk and window seals, heating system malfunctions, frozen or blank display screens, body control module failures, and blacked-out gauges while driving.

The more expensive Model S sedan and Model X falcon-wing SUV have received numerous complaints about electrical and hardware faults. With the potential for various issues, it’s essential to consider the cost of repairing a Tesla before making a purchase.

Related: 15 Reasons Why People Hate Tesla (And Why They Might Be Right)

The Price Of Repairing Your Tesla

The specific costs of repairs will vary depending on your location. If your vehicle is still under warranty, repairs must be done at a Tesla shop to maintain the warranty coverage. You can find estimated costs online, but keep in mind that they are not set in stone. To reduce costs, stay updated on recalls, as they are fixed by Tesla at no charge. Additionally, following the recommended maintenance routines can prevent major repairs.

It’s true that you’ll save on ordinary maintenance like oil changes with a Tesla, but the average repair cost for a Tesla vehicle is estimated to be $832 per year, compared to $652 for an average vehicle, according to RepairPal. Tesla repairs are 27% more expensive than repairs for comparable gas-powered vehicles. Due to limited availability and production, Tesla parts are not as mass-produced as those for high-volume vehicles, which contributes to the higher repair costs. However, as time goes on and Tesla cars become more widespread, this issue may improve.

Related: 15 Reasons Why You Should Buy A Tesla

Here’s How The Models Performed – Best And Worst

The Model 3 has the highest reliability rating among Tesla models. It is on par with other vehicles in its class, including those with traditional internal combustion engines. Despite the cost of maintenance and repairs, Consumer Reports actively recommends the Model 3 as a worthwhile purchase.

On the other hand, the Model Y has a lower reliability rating compared to other vehicles in its class. Since its introduction, the Model Y has been recalled four times for issues related to tire pressure loss, wheel alignment concerns, and problems with the automated emergency braking (AEB) system, which can cause sudden stops in traffic.

The Model S is Tesla’s flagship car, known for its practical design and impressive performance. However, electronics, body components, and suspension issues have affected its reliability ratings in recent years.

The Model X ranks lower than other vehicles in its class, but it is not at the bottom. It shares many problems with other Tesla models, possibly due to the focus on autonomous driving rather than ensuring all safety and driver assistance features work flawlessly.

2023 Tesla Rankings

Related: What Tesla’s Insane Price Cuts For The Model S And X Really Mean

The Final Summation On Tesla Cars

Overall, Tesla cars do not have the best reliability reputation. Maintenance and repairs for Tesla vehicles can be costly. It is essential to spend ample time researching and considering various factors before making a decision to purchase a Tesla. However, as electric vehicles become more established, Tesla’s reliability is expected to improve, along with the availability of parts.