There’s an age-old theory that suggests using narrower tires in the winter for more grip due to increased pressure on a smaller contact patch. The alternative argument is in favor of wider tires, as they offer more surface area for increased grip. However, according to Jonathan Benson at Tyre Reviews, whether you opt for wider or narrower tires for your winter setup doesn’t make much of a difference.
Benson wanted to put the wider versus narrower winter tires theory to the test, so he obtained four sets of Hankook tires to test on a BMW 3 Series on a snow-covered closed course, with each set of tires being wider than the previous. The tires ranged from 205 section-width up to 275s, with the 205s fitted on 16-inch wheels, the 225s on 18s, and the 255s and 275s on 19-inch rims.
Although there were subjective differences in feel and feedback between the sizes, the data revealed that the narrowest tire performed the best in acceleration testing but the worst in braking. For lap times, the middle 225 section-width tire performed the best. However, the results were so close that any difference would likely not be noticeable.
The primary conclusion from Tyre Reviews is that the objective performance of a good winter tire versus a bad winter tire of the same size shows more variation. Therefore, when shopping for winter tires, it’s better to focus on brands with good reviews rather than stress about the tire size.